I remember a movie called White Chicks with Shawn and Marlon Wayans. It was funny and it was not made to offend anyone. It is only a comedy and it shows two men, in an attempt to protect two wealthy heiresses, dressing up as women of the another race and altering their attitudes to try and match those of the heiresses. Is a movie like this culturally and racially insensitive?
I remember seeing Robert Downey, Jr. dressed as a black man and talking with this military, macho, deep voice, that I guess was supposed to be similar to a black man's. In Tropic Thunder, he's playing "the dude playing a dude, disguised as another dude."
I laughed. I love Robert Downey, Jr. and in any role he plays, he can bring it to life with his talent. Did I find this role racist or insensitive? Not at all.
Did I find Franchesca's video, "Shit White Girls say to Black Girls" offensive or racist? No. I think that stuff like this happens sometimes with any race and between two individuals with different backgrounds and a lack of knowledge of the background. A conversation where things said in the video are said between two or more people does happen. But guess what? It's not just white girl to black girl. I've seen black girls say crazy things to white girls as well.
Her video taught a lesson that I think some people are failing to understand. Think before you speak. Sometimes some people are not sure about how to communicate with someone of a different race or that has a different background than their own.
My cousin, who grew up in a more wealthier part of town, treated me and my brother weirdly. While my cousin has a personality that matches those he grew up around, those he went to school with, and those he likely hang around, he assumed my brother and I behaved in the way blacks are stereotyped or usually seen as behaving. I was offended by that because if he talked to me more than once a year for holiday gathers, I think he'd see that I'm quite the nerd and do not match up to the stereotypes at all. (Search the world and you'll never find another me. If you do, please tell them I said hello and would like to meet them!)
My mom works with a white lady who says crazy stuff all the time to the people she work with. My mom, who is black, my mom's friend who is a Mexican woman, and another guy who is Asian (I'm not exactly sure about his nationality) who is also gay. When my mom first told me the things she say on a regular basis, I was mad. It took my mom to show me that she didn't know many people that were from a different background. The people she worked with was her real world. It happens.
I've had friends of different races in college. More so in college than in high school. We never treated each other like in this video. Normal interactions between people of different races also happen. I think normal interactions are possible and should happen more often. (I'm not saying they don't. I'm not very social, so I don't know how everyone interacts with everyone.)
In Frachesca's video, I think she's depicting a person--take away race for a moment--who likely has not spent much time around a person of another race or from a different. In cases like this, like with my cousin, in order to relate to that them, a person will rely on stereotypes because it's the most available bit of information that they can think of when trying to relate to someone of another race. It happens. I don't find it racist, but I do consider it ignorant. I believe racism is intentional and made to hurt by suggesting that one race is superior than another. This video and the movies I mentioned before, were not made to do such a thing. The movies were made to be funny. The video was made to be funny.
So that you don't wind up treating others like this, if this is you and you being of any race, I just say adopt a new way of thinking. Everyone is human. Humans are complex and diverse. The color of their skin does not influence their behavior. Stereotypical behavior towards those of that race are not true for the entire race. Making assumptions hurt because you are not acknowledging the possiblity that this person is an individual and not a part of one massive group that think, speak, and act the same way.
There are differences from person to person in every race. Some try to act a certain way to fit in with those around them. Then there are some, like me, who don't fit in at all because they have a mother that taught them differently.
And just in case you are, stop acting like this is the initiation of some sort of race war because it's not. Watch the video and think about it. Do you know of some people, no matter the race, that say things related more to stereotypes when you are conversing with a person of a different race? Do you do this? You may not do it with the accent, but we all know of stereotypes because we see them in the media all of the time. It's time to put that away and to start treating everyone like they are a person, no matter their differences.
Did the video hurt you in anyway? Did it make you feel uncomfortable? If yes to either or both questions, why?
Type in the title of the video on Youtube and see what comes up. There are more parodies. They are making a point and not attacking or labeling anyone specific or a group of people.
*Pictures are not mine but taken from two other blogs and I'm not sure of the source.*
Chatboard (0)